Section 19A in Scotland: Late Injury Claims Explained

Section 19A of the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973 lets a Scottish court allow a personal injury claim to go ahead after the normal three-year time limit has run out, if the judge thinks it is equitable. It is a safety valve, not a right. The court has a wide discretion, but the person bringing the claim has to persuade the judge, and many late claims fail. The safest route is to start your claim well inside the three years.
This guide explains what the section says, how Scottish judges use it, what weighs for and against a late claim, and what to do if you are close to the deadline or past it. It covers personal injury claims in Scotland only. Other Scottish Acts also contain a “section 19A”, for example in crofting law, but they have nothing to do with injury claims.
Scotland Claims Injury Lawyers
Get Help With a Late Injury Claim
Scotland Claims Injury Lawyers connects people in Scotland with specialist injury lawyers for claims involving accidents or negligence.
Visit Scotland Claims
TL;DR
- Section 19A gives a Scottish court a discretion to let an injury claim proceed even though the three-year time limit has passed.
- The discretion is wide, but the burden is on the injured person to persuade the judge, and courts do not treat it as automatic.
- Judges weigh the reason for the delay, the strength of the claim and the unfairness to the other side of defending an old case.
- Time usually runs from the date of injury, or from when you knew, or reasonably could have known, the key facts, so the exact start date matters.
- If you are near the deadline or past it, speak to a solicitor straight away. We offer free claim assessments on a no win no fee basis.
Table of Contents
What section 19A actually says
The Scottish time limit for most injury claims is three years. Section 19A is the exception to it. Under the wording of the Act, where a person would be entitled to bring an action but for the time limits in section 17, 18, 18A or 18B, the court may allow the action to proceed if it seems equitable to do so. The section also cross-refers to section 19AA, so the full text is worth reading for your own situation.
Two practical points follow from the statute:
The Scottish Government has described the position in similar terms. A ministerial submission to the Scottish Parliament in June 2022 confirmed that section 19A empowers the court to disapply the time limit and that this discretion is unfettered. It also said that the overwhelming majority of relevant civil cases are expected to start within the three years. In other words, the safety valve exists, but the system assumes you will use the normal period.
The three-year rule that section 19A overrides
To understand when 19A matters, you need to know when the clock starts. Under the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973, as amended, the usual period for personal injury actions is three years. It runs from the date the injuries were sustained, or from when a continuing act or omission ended if that is later.
There is also a “date of knowledge” rule. If it is later, the three years can run from when you became aware, or could reasonably have become aware, of three things:
- that the injury was sufficiently serious to justify bringing an action;
- that it was attributable to an act or omission;
- who was responsible, or who the employer or principal of the responsible person was.
For claims after a death, the same three-year pattern applies from the date of death or the later date of knowledge.
This matters because many people who think they are “out of time” are not. A back injury from years of lifting, or a condition that took time to be linked to a workplace, may have a later start date than the day of the accident. Section 19A comes into play only once the properly calculated period has expired.
Our own guides go into the detail of the ordinary rule: the personal injury claim time limit in Scotland and the statute of limitations for personal injury are good starting points. If your injury happened at work, see the work accident claim time limit and the 3-year rule.
How Scottish judges decide whether to allow a late claim
Because the statute simply says “equitable”, the detail comes from case law. The leading approach is set out in Chinn v Cyclacel Ltd (2013). The court balances the interests and conduct of the parties and their advisers, the nature, circumstances and prospects of the claim, and the prejudice either side may suffer. No single factor is conclusive. The broad question is where the equities lie.
The burden is on the person bringing the claim
In Chinn, the court held that the burden of satisfying the court rests on the pursuer. Although the discretion is unqualified, it must be used within limits set by earlier decisions. In practice, you need a convincing explanation, not just a request.
The Court of Session made this point sharply in Jacobsen v Chaturvedi (2017). It is not enough to say the three years have gone and the case should be allowed to continue. There must be additional circumstances cogent enough to justify taking away what has become the defender’s complete defence.
Prejudice to the other side
One of the most quoted passages comes from the House of Lords in AS v Poor Sisters of Nazareth. Lord Hope said that proof that the defender faces a real possibility of significant prejudice will usually decide the issue in the defender’s favour. The reasoning is that time bars exist so that people are not forced to defend old claims where evidence has faded.
In an everyday injury case, that prejudice might be:
- witnesses who can no longer be traced or no longer remember;
- records, CCTV or site inspection evidence that no longer exists;
- an employer or occupier that has changed hands or closed.
The reason for the delay
Courts look hard at why the claim was not raised in time. In Irving v The Advocate General for Scotland (2012), the judge refused to use the discretion because the pursuer had delayed in consulting a solicitor for no good reason, and the equities were evenly balanced. By contrast, in E.A. v G.N. (2015) the Court of Session upheld a decision to allow a time-barred claim, taking account of the pursuer’s personal circumstances and when she was first told she might have a right of action. It also confirmed that the discretion is unfettered, and an appeal court will interfere only if the first judge took account of something irrelevant, left out something important, or reached an unreasonable decision.

An alternative remedy counts against you
If the real reason a claim is late is that someone else let you down, the court may point you elsewhere. In Jacobsen, the judges noted that an alternative remedy, such as an action against the pursuer’s own solicitors, is a factor against allowing a late claim. The stronger that alternative case, the more likely the court is to refuse. In Chinn, the court refused the application partly because the pursuer had already had a full opportunity to bring her claim with legal representation.
Section 19A at a glance
| Factor |
Tends to help a late claim |
Tends to hurt a late claim |
| Reason for delay |
Genuine, well explained, outside your control |
Unexplained or avoidable delay |
| Evidence |
Records, witnesses and documents still available |
Key evidence lost or faded |
| Other side’s position |
Little or no real prejudice |
Real risk of significant prejudice |
| Strength of the claim |
Good prospects on the facts |
Weak or uncertain prospects |
| Other options |
No other remedy available |
A possible claim against earlier advisers |
| Speed once you knew |
Prompt advice and action |
Further delay after finding out |
This table summarises themes from the decisions above. It is a guide to how judges think, not a prediction for any individual case.
Is the law likely to change?
The Scottish Law Commission looked at this area in its 2007 report on personal injury limitation. It recommended extending the limitation period from three to five years while keeping the date-of-knowledge test and the court’s discretion. It also recommended amending section 19A so that it lists the factors a court may take into account, on the basis that a list would help legal representatives when pleading their case. Those recommendations do not change what you should do today: the three-year period is the one that applies, and you should plan around it.

Why you should not rely on section 19A
Section 19A is a last resort. Three reasons stand out:
- It adds a whole extra hurdle. Before the court even looks at how much your injury is worth, you have to win the argument about time.
- It adds cost and delay. A contested time-bar argument means more court work and more waiting.
- The outcome is uncertain. With a broad discretion and no fixed checklist, even strong cases can be refused.
The simple answer is to avoid needing it. Gather your details, get advice early and raise the claim inside the period. Our guide on why acting quickly after an accident matters explains how early action protects evidence as well as time.
What to do if you are close to the deadline or past it
If the three years are close to ending, or you think they may already have ended, work through these steps.
- Write down the key dates. Note when the accident happened, when symptoms started, when you first saw a doctor and when you first realised someone else might be responsible.
- Work out the real start date. The clock may start from the accident or from your date of knowledge. A solicitor can assess which applies to you.
- Gather what you still have. Medical records, photographs, accident report forms, employer correspondence, witness names and any insurance letters all help.
- Speak to a solicitor immediately. Do not wait to see whether your injury improves. Delay after you have taken advice can weigh against you if you later ask the court to apply section 19A.
- Ask what the options are. If the claim is still in time, it can be raised properly. If it is not, a solicitor can say whether there is a realistic argument for the court to use its discretion.
If you are unsure which kind of accident you fall under, these pages cover the common types: injury at work, slips and trips, whiplash and back injuries. For a wider overview of your position, see our guide to personal injury rights in Scotland. If your accident happened at work, our accident at work time limit guide covers the specifics.
Our perspective
In our experience, the biggest problem with time limits is not the law itself. It is that people do not realise how quickly three years pass, especially when they are focusing on recovery, going back to work or dealing with insurers.
Section 19A exists, but we would never want a client to depend on it. A judge has to be persuaded that it is fair to let an old claim continue, and the other side can argue that time has damaged its ability to defend. A claim raised within the three years avoids that fight altogether.
That is why we make the first step easy. Our claim assessment is free, and you can ask for a callback at a time that suits you. Our service is regulated by the Law Society of Scotland, and we work on a no win no fee basis, so you pay nothing upfront.
We also think the cost of a claim should be clear from the start. Many larger firms take a success fee of 20% including VAT from your compensation. We charge 15% plus VAT. If your claim is not successful, you pay no fee.
If you are unsure whether you are in time, ask us before you assume the answer. It costs nothing to find out where you stand.
Roger
Start your claim with a free assessment
If you were injured in an accident that was not your fault, we can tell you whether you are within the time limit and what the next step is. Our specialist solicitors handle road traffic accidents, accidents at work, slips and trips, whiplash and motorcycle accidents in Scotland. You can read how our no win no fee personal injury claims work, request a callback, or use our compensation calculator to get an idea of the value of your claim. We do not charge anything upfront, and we charge 15% plus VAT on a successful claim.
FAQ
What is section 19A in Scotland?
Section 19A of the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973 allows a court to let a personal injury claim proceed even though the time limit has expired, if it seems equitable. It is a judge’s discretion, not an automatic right. The person bringing the claim must persuade the court.
How long do I have to make a personal injury claim in Scotland?
The usual period is three years. It normally runs from the date of the injury, or from the later date when you knew, or could reasonably have known, the key facts about your injury and who was responsible. A solicitor can confirm the exact start date in your case.
Will a court always allow a late claim if I had a good reason?
No. A good reason helps, but the court also looks at the strength of the claim and whether the other side would be significantly prejudiced by having to defend it. Cases such as Jacobsen v Chaturvedi show that simply saying the time has expired is not enough. There must be further persuasive circumstances.
Can I use section 19A if I waited because I was recovering?
Possibly, but it depends on the facts. A court will look at why you could not act, what you did once able to, and whether evidence is still available. Because the outcome is uncertain, it is much safer to seek advice early and raise your claim within the three years.
Does it cost anything to find out whether my claim is in time?
Not with us. We offer a free claim assessment, and our claims run on a no win no fee basis with no upfront costs. If we take your case and it succeeds, our fee is 15% plus VAT of your compensation.
Sources
Recommended