Public Liability Claims in Scotland: Your Rights After an Injury

Visitor recovering after a trip inside Scottish public building

A public liability claim is a claim for compensation after you are injured in a public place or on someone else’s property because they failed to take reasonable care. That might be a shop, a restaurant, a car park, a pavement, a leisure centre or a block of flats. In Scotland the claim is made against the organisation or person responsible for the place, and it is normally paid by their insurer. You do not pay that insurance. Their business does. Your job is to show what happened, who was responsible and what it cost you.

We handle these claims for injured people across Scotland on a no win no fee basis. You pay nothing upfront, and you pay no fee if the claim is lost. Our fee if we win is 15% plus VAT of your compensation, where many large firms take up to 20% including VAT. The rest of this guide explains how a claim works, so that you can judge your own situation.

Scotland Claims Injury Lawyers
Get Help With a Public Liability Claim
Scotland Claims Injury Lawyers helps people across Scotland pursue personal injury claims on a no win no fee basis, with no upfront costs.
Visit

TL;DR

  • A public liability claim covers injuries caused by someone’s failure to keep a place reasonably safe: wet floors, broken paving, loose handrails, poor lighting and similar hazards.
  • In Scotland the usual deadline to start court proceedings is three years, so photographs, witness names and medical records are worth gathering straight away.
  • You need to show the other party owed you a duty of care, that they fell short, and that the failure caused your injury.
  • Our no win no fee service means no upfront costs and no fee if your claim is lost. If we win, our fee is 15% plus VAT.

Table of Contents

What a public liability claim actually is

The phrase “public liability” is used in two ways. Businesses buy public liability insurance to cover claims from customers and visitors. If you have been hurt, you are on the other side: you are making a claim that the insurance responds to. This guide is for the injured person.

Scots law calls the person claiming the pursuer and the person they claim against the defender. Compensation is called damages. You will see those words in letters from insurers and in court papers.

The claim rests on negligence, which means a failure to take the care that could reasonably be expected. You are not asking for compensation just because you were hurt somewhere. You are saying that someone responsible for the place or the activity did not do what they reasonably should have done, and you were hurt as a result.

Typical examples:

  • Slipping on a spilled drink or a freshly mopped floor with no warning sign.
  • Tripping on a cracked pavement, a pothole in a car park or a raised paving slab.
  • Being struck by falling stock, signage or a poorly secured fitting.
  • Falling on an unlit or unmaintained stairway in a shared building.
  • Injury caused by faulty equipment at a gym, play park or leisure venue.

If you were hurt at work, or in a road accident, the same principles apply but different rules and routes fit better. We cover that below.

Who can be held responsible

Responsibility usually follows control of the place. The person or organisation that occupies or controls the premises owes a duty to take reasonable care for people who come onto them. In Scotland this comes from the Occupiers’ Liability (Scotland) Act 1960. In summary, the occupier must show the care that is reasonable in all the circumstances regarding dangers from the state of the premises or from things done or left undone on them.

In practice the defender could be:

Where it happened Who may be responsible
Shop, supermarket, restaurant, pub The business occupying the premises, sometimes also a cleaning or maintenance contractor
Pavement, road surface, public park The local council or the body responsible for maintaining it
Shared stairway or common area The owner, factor or property manager, depending on who maintains it
Event, venue or leisure centre The operator or organiser
Car park The owner or operator of the car park

Working out who is responsible is often the hardest part for an injured person, because maintenance is frequently contracted out. A solicitor can write to the likely parties and ask for their maintenance and inspection records. You do not have to be certain who is responsible before you ask for advice.

What you need to prove

Three things matter in most public liability cases.

  1. A duty of care. The defender was responsible for the place or activity where you were hurt.
  2. A failure to take reasonable care. The hazard was something they knew about or should have found and dealt with, within a reasonable time.
  3. Causation. The injury happened because of that failure, not for some unrelated reason.

Timing is central. A spillage that appeared thirty seconds before you slipped is very different from a leak that had been there all morning. The Scottish Legal Aid Board’s guidance on reparation (injury compensation) cases says that in tripping cases the evidence should cover who was responsible for maintenance, how long the defect had existed and whether steps should have been taken to fix it.

That is why details such as cleaning rotas, inspection logs and previous complaints can decide a case, and why asking for them early matters.

Evidence to gather after an accident

Strong evidence is the single biggest influence on how smoothly a claim runs. The Scottish Legal Aid Board lists the kind of material a case is built on: photographs and sketches of the hazard, medical reports, expert reports on liability or cause, and documents such as wage certificates, contracts, police reports or receipts.

Turning that into a practical list:

  • Get medical attention first. Your health comes first, and the record of your injury and when it was found is central to the claim.
  • Photograph the hazard. Take pictures of the spill, the crack, the missing sign or the broken light, from a few angles and with something for scale, before it is cleaned or repaired.
  • Note the exact place and time. A rough sketch or a pin on a map helps.
  • Report it. Tell the manager, venue or council and ask for the accident to be written in the accident book. Ask for a copy or take a photograph of the entry.
  • Collect witness details. Names and phone numbers are enough. Memories fade fast.
  • Keep your footwear and clothing as they were, if the way you fell may matter.
  • Keep every receipt. Prescriptions, travel to appointments, taxis, and any lost pay all count towards your losses. Wage slips show lost earnings.
  • Write down what happened while it is fresh, including what you were doing, what you could see and what you were wearing on your feet.

Avoid giving a recorded statement to an insurer who contacts you before you have taken advice. A short, accurate account, written when you are ready, serves you better than a rushed phone call.

What you can claim for

Compensation in Scotland is made up of two main parts.

Scottish injury compensation’s two main components

Solatium is the award for pain, suffering and loss of amenity, meaning the way the injury affects your life and what you can enjoy doing. The size of the award depends on the injury, its severity and how long it lasts.

Patrimonial loss is the financial side: lost earnings, medical costs, travel, care and help you needed from family, and the cost of adapting your life or home if the injury is serious.

In very serious cases involving a shortened life expectancy, the Damages (Scotland) Act 2011 sets particular rules, including how the “lost years” of earnings are calculated, with a 25% deduction for living expenses.

No reliable figure can be given without knowing your injury and recovery. If you want a starting point, our guide to how personal injury compensation is calculated in Scotland explains how awards are built up, and our claim calculator guide shows how to use an estimate sensibly.

Time limits in Scotland

The general rule is three years. Under section 17 of the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973, a personal injury action had to be started within three years of the injury, or later in some continuing cases. The same section allows extra time where the injured person was under a legal disability, such as being a child or lacking capacity, when the right to claim arose.

Citizens Advice Scotland puts it plainly: for the common negligence claim, court proceedings must start within three years of becoming aware of the injury.

Two practical points follow.

  • Three years is for starting court proceedings, not for first contacting a solicitor. Evidence, witnesses and CCTV disappear long before the deadline, and many insurers will not settle at the last minute.
  • Specific rules apply to children and to cases where the injury only became apparent later. If either describes you, get advice early rather than counting the years yourself.

The clock for a claim by a parent on behalf of a child is different from an adult’s. For road crashes, mygov.scot states a child under 16 can be claimed for until they turn 19.

How a public liability claim runs

Every case is different, but most follow the same sequence.

  1. Free assessment. A specialist solicitor looks at what happened, where, and who may be responsible, and tells you whether the claim has prospects.
  2. Signing up. If you go ahead, you sign a no win no fee agreement. You pay nothing upfront.
  3. Investigating. The solicitor gathers your evidence, requests the defender’s records, and obtains a medical report on your injury and recovery.
  4. Notifying the defender. The solicitor writes to the occupier or their insurer setting out the claim. In Scottish practice a claimant’s case also needs a clear account of the facts, the duties of care said to be owed and the loss suffered.
  5. Negotiating. The insurer investigates and either admits responsibility, denies it or offers a share. Most claims settle here, without a court hearing.
  6. Court, only if needed. If no fair settlement is possible, proceedings are raised in court before the time limit runs out.
  7. Payment. Compensation is paid by the insurer and passed to you after our agreed fee is deducted.

If the other side disputes liability or blames you

Insurers often argue that the hazard was visible, that you were not looking where you were going or that the area was inspected regularly. This is common and does not mean your claim is weak.

In Scotland, if you are found partly to blame, the compensation is generally reduced to reflect your share, rather than being lost completely. A claim where you carry some of the responsibility can therefore still be worth bringing. A solicitor will weigh the argument against the evidence: how obvious the hazard was, whether warnings were present, and how long it had been there.

This is where records the defender must keep, such as inspection logs and complaints about the same spot, carry weight. The earlier we are involved, the more likely that material is preserved.

Public liability, workplace and road claims compared

The label matters because it affects who you claim against and what evidence helps.

Type of claim Typical situation Usually claimed against Our page
Public liability Injury in a shop, street, venue or shared building The occupier or the body responsible for the place Slip and trip claims
Workplace injury Injury while working, from unsafe equipment or systems Your employer Injury at work claims
Road traffic Injury as a driver, passenger, cyclist or pedestrian in a crash The at-fault driver’s insurer Road traffic accident claims

If you were injured as a pedestrian on a pavement because of a defect, that is a public liability claim. If a vehicle hit you, it is a road claim. If you were on the clock when you were hurt, even in a public place, it may be an employer claim. Overlaps are common, so describe what happened to us in your own words and we will place it correctly. Our guide to public liability accident claims in Scotland goes into more examples.

What no win no fee means for you

Most people hesitate over cost more than anything else. mygov.scot notes that most solicitors take cases on a no win, no fee basis, with a cap on the percentage fee they can take.

With us:

  • You pay no upfront costs.
  • If the claim is lost, you pay no fee.
  • If the claim is won, our fee is 15% plus VAT of your compensation.
  • Other large firms charge 20% including VAT.

That difference stays with you. On a settlement of £10,000, a fee of 20% including VAT takes £2,000, while 15% plus VAT takes £1,500 plus VAT of £300, a total of £1,800. The calculation is simple, and it is worth running with any firm’s figures before you sign anything.

We are regulated by the Law Society of Scotland, and offer fast free claim assessments and a 24-hour callback or helpline.

Why the way you claim matters

You could write to the insurer yourself, but you would be dealing with a team whose job is to limit what is paid. They will ask for documents you may not know exist, and may suggest a quick settlement before the full effect of your injury is known. A specialist solicitor works out the whole value of the claim, including losses that arrive months later, and takes on the correspondence, deadlines and negotiation. We aim to secure the maximum compensation you are entitled to, so the work and the risk are ours.

Our view

Most of the public liability enquiries that matter begin with a simple worry: “It was only a fall, am I making a fuss?” It is not a fuss. Shops, councils and landlords carry insurance exactly so that people hurt by an unsafe place are compensated.

What holds people back is cost and uncertainty. That is why we work on a no win no fee basis, with no upfront costs, and why we keep our fee at 15% plus VAT. The money you recover is yours, and we want you to keep as much of it as possible.

Our advice is to act while the evidence is fresh. Take photographs, report the accident, see a doctor, and call us before you speak to the insurer. A free assessment tells you where you stand, with nothing to pay and nothing to lose.

Roger

Start your claim

If you were hurt in a public place in Scotland because someone failed to keep it safe, our specialist solicitors will assess your case for free and explain your options. You can request a callback or use the online form on our personal injury compensation claim page. If you were hurt on a pavement, in a shop or on stairs, our slip and trip claims page is the closest fit.

FAQ

Do I need to have been seriously hurt to claim?

No. The claim rests on someone’s failure to take reasonable care and on the injury and losses it caused. Many successful claims involve injuries that heal in weeks or months. The size of compensation depends on the severity and your recovery, so an assessment is the best way to find out what is realistic.

How long do I have to make a public liability claim in Scotland?

The usual limit is three years to start court proceedings, as set by the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973. Different rules apply to children and to people who could not act for themselves. Do not wait until the deadline, because evidence is easiest to secure soon after the accident.

What if I was partly to blame for the accident?

You can still claim. If you are found partly responsible, compensation is generally reduced to reflect your share rather than refused altogether. Tell your solicitor everything honestly, including what you were doing and whether warnings were present, so the case can be assessed accurately.

Will I have to pay anything upfront?

No. We work on a no win no fee basis, so there are no upfront costs, and if your claim is lost you pay no fee. If the claim is won, our fee is 15% plus VAT of your compensation.

Do I have to go to court?

Most claims are settled through negotiation with the defender’s insurer. Court proceedings are raised only if a fair settlement cannot be reached, and they must begin within the time limit. Your solicitor will explain the position at each stage.

Sources