Based on reporting by BBC News, 19 November 2026. All rights in the original report remain with the publisher.
What was reported
A consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has publicly called for a corporate homicide investigation into claims that a number of patients died avoidable deaths over a period of years, according to BBC News. The surgeon said he had been raising concerns about surgical care at NHS Grampian for approximately a decade, bringing those concerns to government ministers and police, but felt he had not been heard.
As reported by BBC News, a leaked expert review from 2022 examined 45 patients who received liver and pancreatic surgery at the hospital between 2015 and 2021. The review is understood to have found that 19 of the 31 patients who died were considered to have died of avoidable consequences of surgery or intervention, and that mortality rates were significantly higher than national benchmarks. The surgeon formally reported concerns about dozens of cases in 2021 and subsequently reported 20 cases to police in 2024, though no charges were brought.
NHS Grampian stated, according to BBC News, that a thorough investigation had already taken place and that any new evidence would be carefully considered. These allegations follow a separate report published the previous week which reportedly identified poor leadership and culture within the NHS Grampian board.
Medical negligence claims in Scotland
When a patient dies or suffers serious harm during NHS care, their family may be entitled to pursue a claim for compensation through the civil courts in Scotland. This is entirely separate from any criminal investigation or public inquiry, and families do not need to wait for the outcome of either before taking legal advice.
In cases of this kind, a claim is typically founded on the legal principle that a duty of care exists between a health board and its patients. Where it can be shown, on the balance of probabilities, that the standard of care fell below what a reasonable body of medical opinion would consider acceptable, and that this failure caused or materially contributed to the patient's death or injury, a claim may proceed. This is known as the Bolam and Hunter v Hanley test in Scots law.
In incidents of this kind, liability often rests with the relevant health board as the employer of the clinical staff involved, rather than with any individual clinician. NHS Scotland health boards are public bodies and can be pursued directly through the civil courts. Each case turns on its own facts, and an independent medical expert is usually instructed to assess the standard of care provided.
Where a death is involved, the relevant legislation in Scotland is the Damages (Scotland) Act 2011. Under that Act, certain close relatives, including a spouse or civil partner, children, and parents, have a right to claim in their own name for the loss they have suffered. This is distinct from any claim the patient's estate itself might bring.
Time limits
In Scotland, the general rule under the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973 is that a personal injury or death claim must be raised within three years. In a death case, that three-year period ordinarily runs from the date of death, or from the date on which the relatives first became aware, or could reasonably have become aware, that the death may have been caused by an act or omission that could give rise to a claim.
Where the circumstances of a death only become apparent later, for example following a public inquiry, a whistleblower disclosure, or the publication of an expert review, the courts have discretion to consider when the relatives could reasonably have known enough to bring a claim. This is known as the "date of knowledge" provision.
Families affected by the allegations concerning NHS Grampian should be aware that, while there is no immediate obligation to act, the three-year rule means it is worth seeking legal advice sooner rather than later. Time limits can pass more quickly than expected, particularly where a death occurred several years ago.
What compensation can cover
Under the Damages (Scotland) Act 2011, compensation available to close relatives following a wrongful death can include the following.
- Loss of support: Where the deceased provided financial support to their family, dependants may claim for the financial loss arising from that person's absence, calculated over a realistic future period.
- Grief and loss of society: This is a sum awarded to reflect the genuine grief, distress, and loss of the deceased person's companionship and guidance. It is recognised in Scots law as a distinct head of damage.
- Funeral costs: Reasonable costs associated with the funeral and burial or cremation can be recovered as part of a claim.
- Services: Where the deceased provided unpaid practical support to the family, such as childcare or household management, the cost of replacing those services may be claimed.
In cases where a patient did not die but suffered serious harm, compensation can include solatium (a sum for pain, suffering, and loss of amenity), loss of earnings, the cost of ongoing care or treatment, and reasonable travel expenses to medical appointments.
Compensation in medical negligence cases involving the NHS is paid by the health board and is funded publicly. Any award is intended to reflect the actual losses suffered and is assessed carefully. Legal fees in these cases are typically met separately, so fees are not deducted from any compensation received.
Frequently asked questions
Can a family pursue a civil claim even if no criminal charges are brought?
Yes. A civil claim and a criminal prosecution are entirely separate processes. The standard of proof in a civil case is lower, requiring the court to be satisfied on the balance of probabilities rather than beyond reasonable doubt. Families do not need to wait for a police investigation or public inquiry to conclude before seeking legal advice about a civil claim.
How do we know whether our relative's death was avoidable?
The first step is usually to obtain the medical records and have them reviewed by an independent medical expert. A specialist solicitor will arrange this. The expert will assess whether the care provided met an acceptable standard and whether any departure from that standard caused or contributed to the death. This process takes time, but it is the foundation of any claim.
Does it matter that the death happened several years ago?
It may not, depending on when the family first had reason to believe the death may have been caused by avoidable failings. The three-year period under the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973 can run from the date of that knowledge rather than the date of death. Families should seek advice promptly to ensure they do not miss any applicable deadline.
Who can claim under the Damages (Scotland) Act 2011?
The Act sets out a list of "relative" claimants who have an automatic right to bring a claim. These include a spouse or civil partner, children of the deceased, and parents. The Act also recognises cohabiting partners who lived with the deceased as husband and wife or as civil partners for a continuous period of at least two years before the death.
Will pursuing a claim affect any ongoing public inquiry or NHS investigation?
A civil compensation claim runs alongside, and does not interfere with, any separate inquiry, investigation, or regulatory process. Health boards and their legal representatives deal with civil claims through established procedures. Pursuing compensation does not prevent families from also engaging with any public inquiry process or making a complaint to the relevant regulatory body.
Based on reporting by BBC News, 19 November 2026. All rights in the original report remain with the publisher.