Based on reporting by BBC News, 20 November 2026. All rights in the original report remain with the publisher.
What was reported
According to BBC News, a man in his 60s who underwent liver surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary says he believes mistakes were made during his care. The patient, who was living in Orkney at the time, had surgery to remove a significant portion of his liver following a stage four cancer diagnosis. During the procedure he reportedly lost a volume of blood far exceeding what the human body normally holds, went into cardiac arrest, and required emergency intervention to restart his heart. He told BBC Scotland that he has never received a full explanation of what went wrong.
The report follows the leaking of an unpublished 2022 review by a consultant at the hospital, as reported by BBC News. That review examined 45 patients who died following liver and pancreatic surgery at the hospital and found that 19 of those deaths were potentially avoidable. NHS Grampian said it was aware of the issues raised and indicated that an investigation had already taken place, though it said it could not comment on individual patients.
Scotland's Patient Safety Commissioner is reported to have raised concerns about the findings. BBC News also notes that the type of liver surgery involved is no longer performed in the NHS Grampian area, with patients now transferred to Edinburgh instead.
Medical negligence claims in Scotland
In Scotland, a claim for medical negligence, known in Scots law as clinical negligence, requires a pursuer to establish two things: first, that the standard of care provided fell below what would reasonably be expected of a competent medical professional in that field; and second, that this substandard care caused or materially contributed to the harm suffered. This is known as establishing both breach of duty and causation.
In incidents of this kind involving surgical procedures, liability often rests with the NHS board responsible for the hospital where the surgery took place. NHS boards in Scotland are legal entities capable of being sued, and claims are typically brought against the relevant board rather than against individual clinicians personally. NHS Grampian would be the relevant board for procedures carried out at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
Medical negligence cases involving complex surgery are frequently supported by independent expert evidence from medical specialists. That expert evidence is used to explain to the court or to the opposing party's legal team what the accepted standard of care was and how, in the pursuer's case, that standard was or was not met. Where an internal review has already identified concerns about a procedure or a series of procedures, that documentation may become relevant to any subsequent legal proceedings, though courts will assess the evidence on its own merits.
Claims of this nature are pursued on a no win, no fee basis. If you win, our success fee is capped at 18% including VAT, below the Scottish statutory maximum, with no hidden extras. Legal costs are recovered from the other side where possible.
Time limits
Under the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973, a person generally has three years from the date of an injury, or from the date they first became aware that their injury may have been caused by a negligent act, to bring a personal injury or clinical negligence claim in Scotland. This is sometimes called the triennium.
In medical negligence cases, the three-year clock can run from the date of the procedure itself, or from the date on which the pursuer first had knowledge that the harm they suffered may have been caused by a potential error rather than by an unavoidable complication. This distinction matters because patients are not always informed of concerns at the time, and may only learn of a possible problem years later, for example when a review is published or when records are disclosed.
The court also has a discretionary power under the 1973 Act to allow a claim to proceed even where the three-year period has passed, if it considers it equitable to do so. However, relying on that discretion carries significant risk and legal advice should be sought as early as possible rather than waiting to see whether the court would exercise it.
Children and adults who lacked legal capacity at the relevant time have separate provisions, with the triennium typically running from the date capacity was regained or, in the case of a child, from the date they turn 16.
What compensation can cover
In a successful clinical negligence claim in Scotland, compensation is made up of a number of distinct elements. These include:
- Solatium - a sum awarded for pain, suffering and loss of amenity. This covers the physical experience of the injury, any psychological impact, and the effect on the pursuer's ability to enjoy life as they did before.
- Loss of earnings - where the negligence has affected the pursuer's ability to work, both past lost income and projected future losses can be claimed.
- Cost of care - if ongoing care or support is required as a result of the harm caused, the reasonable cost of that care may be recoverable, whether provided by a professional or by a family member.
- Medical treatment and rehabilitation - the cost of treatment needed to address the consequences of the negligent procedure, including physiotherapy, psychological support, or further surgical intervention.
- Travel and other outlays - reasonable costs incurred attending medical appointments or receiving treatment as a result of the harm can be included as a head of claim.
Compensation in Scotland is intended to put the pursuer, so far as money can, back in the position they would have been in had the negligence not occurred. Awards are assessed individually and are not inflated as a punitive measure.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if I have a valid medical negligence claim in Scotland?
To have a valid claim, you need to show that the care you received fell below the standard of a reasonably competent clinician in that field, and that this directly caused your injury or worsened your condition. An independent medical expert will usually review your records to advise on this. Not every poor outcome amounts to negligence, so specialist legal advice is the right first step.
Can I claim if I was not told about an internal review into my surgery?
Yes. Patients are not always informed when hospitals carry out internal reviews, and a lack of communication does not prevent a claim. If you later learn that concerns were raised about the care you received, the three-year limitation period may run from the date you first had knowledge of that, rather than from the date of the original procedure.
Who is the claim made against if the surgery took place in an NHS hospital?
In Scotland, claims arising from NHS hospital treatment are generally brought against the NHS board responsible for that hospital. For surgery carried out at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, the relevant board is NHS Grampian. Claims are not usually made directly against individual surgeons or nurses.
What if the harm has had a long-term effect on my health and daily life?
Long-term consequences are taken into account in the assessment of compensation. Solatium covers the ongoing impact on your quality of life, and future losses including care needs, loss of future earnings and treatment costs can all be included. A schedule of loss prepared by your legal team sets out each head of claim with supporting evidence.
How long does a medical negligence claim take to resolve in Scotland?
Complex surgical negligence claims can take several years to resolve, particularly where expert evidence is needed and where the NHS board contests liability or the extent of the harm. Many cases settle before reaching a full court hearing. Your solicitor should keep you updated at each stage and explain the likely timetable for your individual circumstances.
Based on reporting by BBC News, 20 November 2026. All rights in the original report remain with the publisher.